Kick Out the Sports!
by Bob Cook
Bob Cook's weekly ruminations on sports appear Mondays in Flak.
It's tough to pinpoint who coined the phrase, "big players make big plays
in big games." Was it John
Madden? Carolina Panthers coach John Fox, prospective author of an
unwritten book his players would call "Drive-By Cliches?" The mother of Philadelphia Phillies shortstop Jimmy Rollins?
Whoever said it first, "big players make big plays in big games" has become the all-encompassing sports clichˇ to describe the big player who, as I understand it, makes big plays in big games. Lately, no big player has made big plays in big games quite like Bo Bice.
Bo Bice, as all of you know, but many of you would like not to admit knowing, is one of the two finalists in the fourth season of "American Idol," the much-derided, much-watched talent show responsible for making us care again about Paula Abdul.
In dispatches about the show, Bo is generally described as a "rocker" because he has long hair and, unlike many competitors, gives off the appearance of having accomplished the trinity of sex, drugs and rock 'n' roll. Bice, of Helena, Ala., meets Carrie Underwood of Checotah,
Okla., in Tuesday's redneck-off to see who you, America, will vote as your new American Idol. (Yikes. You can tell I've watched this too much because I've started to sound like unctuous host Ryan Seacrest. Parenthetical, out!)
After the Detroit Pistons sent Reggie Miller into
retirement last week by booting his Indiana Pacers out of the NBA playoffs, many speculated on who might replace Miller as the embodiment of a clutch player. In the absence of anyone in actual sports, I will nominate the man his parents call Harold Jr.
 |
|
 |
If you saw last Tuesday's show, you know what I'm talking about. It was the final three, featuring Bice, Underwood (in dispatches about the show, she's generally described as a "country girl" because she is a girl from the country) and Vonzell Solomon (in dispatches about the show, he's generally described as a soul singer because she is black.) As with every week, each competitor had to sing a song based on some proscribed criteria. Last week, each had to sing three songs. In reverse order of appearance, the songs would be one
picked by one of the show's three judges, one picked by the singers themselves, and one picked by the future producer of the winner's album, the zombiefied music legend known as Clive Davis.
In all three songs, Solomon seemed very nervous. But that was no shock; the previous week, by breaking down and blubbering onstage when judge Abdul mentioned she (Solomon, not the scandal-tarred
Abdul) had a rough day, Solomon proved she was not a big player who made big plays in big games. When Seacrest told Solomon on last Wednesday's show that she was voted out, she seemed almost relieved it was over, like Peyton Manning after
another butt-kicking from the New England Patriots.
Meanwhile, Bice, who all season was up and down, falling in the middle of
the pack, or even the end of it at some points in the competition, put on
the performance of the season.
All season, he had used his chops as a performer (at 29 and with many years' experience singing in bands, Bice had far more experience than most "Idol" contestants), to get himself through weeks like the disco theme and the show tunes theme, stuff that wasn't exactly in Bice's Lynyrd Skynyrd wheelhouse. Bice often was lumped in with fellow long-haired
"rocker" Constantine Maroulis, so he benefited when Maroulis got cocky and began favoring his Simon
Cowell-dubbed "Smoldering Idol" stage presence over his actual singing, getting him knocked out sixth-from-last, much earlier than
expected.
Indeed, Bice saved his best for the final quarter, last week making himself look like Michael Jordan and Underwood, his competition for this week, look like Bryon Russell.
Bice first nailed Davis' choice of Elton John's "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me," showing a range of voice and emotion he hadn't previously delivered. His Corpseness Davis was very enthused. Then, Bice decided to go a capella with his next choice "In a Dream" by Badlands and sang it on pitch, as judge Randy Jackson likes to say, and with conviction that no other contestant could match. Davis right there told him they'd be making a record together soon.
This was the equivalent of the 35-foot 3-pointer with the shot-clock at one second Bice had killed with a no-instrument version of an obscure hair metal song.
Underwood, a top vote-getter all season, was a nervous wreck following Bice. "I wouldn't want to follow Bo," notoriously acerbic judge Cowell so tenderly put it to young Carrie. She wasn't horrible, but Bice had exposed the Shania Twain wannabe's every flaw, particuarly her extremely wooden stage presence and her soulless delivery. (Underwood shouldn't feel too bad Linda Ronstadt made a killing in the 1970s in a similar vein as a country-pop empty vessel. For that matter, so has Twain.) Davis moved his lips as wide as he could in
praise of Underwood, but he wasn't practically offering a record deal on
the spot.
There's no guarantee Bice will bring his "A" game on Tuesday night's finale. But he's asserted himself as impervious in the face of pressure. He's Reggie Miller hitting a huge shot, Tom Brady tossing the winning touchdown pass, Bud Selig coming up with a draconian
steroid policy before Congress imposes one. Until further notice, Bice
is the epitome of a big player making big plays in big games. Even Jimmy
Rollins' mother would agree.
E-mail Bob Cook at bobc@flakmag.com.
graphic by Andy Ross